The Breakdown: Can YOU Bend a Bullet?

Physicist Adam Weiner analyzes the magic behind Wanted's mind-bending ballistics


It appears we have yet another “Matrix-like” action fantasy violence-fest in the just-released movie Wanted starring James McAvoy, Angelina Jolie and Morgan Freeman. The curving-bullet scene we see in the trailer is fast becoming a topic of conversation in certain moviegoing circles (i.e. high-school kids). It appears that McAvoy applies a little “English” to the bullet with that fancy flip of the wrist. Now, clearly the scene is just silly fantasy –curving a bullet a couple of feet around a butchered pig does not conform to the physics of the known universe. However, the interesting question is whether or not it might be possible to manipulate the gun to impart any kind of curve at all.

Ballistics is a rather complicated topic. When a bullet is fired out of the barrel of a gun it can have a velocity of up to 1000 m/s and a rotation rate up to hundreds of thousands of rpm. It is immediately subjected to the downward pull of gravity, and a large air-drag force slowing the bullet down. While the rotation stabilizes the bullet by the same principle that a spinning gyroscope is hard to knock over (conservation of momentum), this same rotation can result in a small upward or downward force along with a sideways drift as a result of the Magnus force. The Magnus force is the same force that makes it possible to throw a wicked curveball—the result of air traveling at different speeds around each side of a rapidly spinning ball, thus creating a different air pressure on each side. Of all of these forces, gravity has the largest effect on the bullet’s trajectory. Over a distance of a five or ten meters like that shown in Wanted’s slaughterhouse scene, the combination of these forces would result in a deflection of a few millimeters— obviously not sufficient to clear Angelina (and the pig) and hit the target.

Acknowledging all of the above, the question that we still need to address is: Could we get any additional help from the wrist flip? Another millimeter? Anything? The answer is (not surprisingly): no, we could not. The reason is very simple and has to do with Newton’s first law of motion. The implication in the scene is that the curving trajectory of the gun is somehow imparted to the bullet before it’s released and the bullet continues to curve after it leaves the barrel of the gun. That’s not the way bullet-firing works. It’s a common first-year physics misconception, for example, that a ball rolling around a curved track will continue in a curved path after it leaves the track. It won’t. The reason an object follows a curved trajectory is because there is a force pulling it into that trajectory—for instance, the walls of the track pushing on the ball. As soon as the forces stop acting, the object is going to continue in a straight line at a constant speed, according to Newton’s first law. Try this at home: Attach a string to a ball and swing it in a horizontal circle just above the ground, and then release it. Notice the path it takes after you release it. It’s a straight line. Same thing with the bullet after it leaves the gun.

Adam Weiner is the author of Don't Try This at Home! The Physics of Hollywood Movies.

22 Comments

Comments

DiGMEH

from Montreal, Quebec

Article Rating: 
0

Well, as a regualr movie go-er, I saw Wanted when it premiered in my city. Before going to the movie, I was biased to think that it was just another aimless/plotless story based on the matrix style. To my surprise, it was actually a good movie with a solid plot. It is really hard these days to come up with new "powers" to give main actors.

Now heading to the bullet being curved, I assume that there could be a way (and I am just imagining since I have no physics backgrous what so ever), to use sequenced magnets to try to curve the bullet (similar system as the magnetic traains use for propulsion). But, in the movie, there are supposingly no tricks used... simple "If someone told you that bullets only flew in a curved way, and you didn't know anything about bullets, you would believe bullets really do travel in a curving manner" (or something of the sort). Well if we use that same principle, then if you bring up a kid and tell him that humans can fly, will it be able to fly? The answer is NO.

- DiGGY

1 out of 6 people found this comment helpful
I found this comment 
 
Article Rating: 
0

Though it is not physically possible ... would it be possible to curve the bullet if your "wrist action" rotation speed was the same speed that the bullet left the gun

2 out of 8 people found this comment helpful
I found this comment 
 
DiGMEH

from Montreal, Quebec

Article Rating: 
0

Well, then the other impossibility is getting your wrist to that speed. It becomes related to the time travel theorem, where one could achieve it if he could accelerate his body to that of light.
- DiGGY

0 out of 3 people found this comment helpful
I found this comment 
 
Article Rating: 
0

Diggy,
You do realize that a bullet travels nowhere near the speed of light, right? A bullet, according to this article, travels at almost Mach 3, but not the speed of sound. Although this does not diminish the practicality nor the possibility of moving one's limb at this speed, I just thought I'd provide the thought for the sake of fact checking.

2 out of 17 people found this comment helpful
I found this comment 
 
Article Rating: 
0

Since we're pointing out people's mistakes here brettsmaname, you do realize that Mach 3 is actually three times the speed of sound. Just thought you would like to be informed. You know, for the sake of fact checking and all.

24 out of 26 people found this comment helpful
I found this comment 
 
Article Rating: 
0

lol

2 out of 6 people found this comment helpful
I found this comment 
 
Article Rating: 
0

it's not actually imposible to curve a bullet its humanly imposible

1 out of 4 people found this comment helpful
I found this comment 
 
Article Rating: 
0

it's not actually imposible to curve a bullet its humanly imposible

1 out of 5 people found this comment helpful
I found this comment 
 
Article Rating: 
0

it's not actually imposible to curve a bullet its humanly imposible

0 out of 3 people found this comment helpful
I found this comment 
 
Article Rating: 
0

to get a bullet to move horizontally (say around one actress) could be done by moving the gun horizontally across the body, of course the speed at which this would be done would have to be very great to have any measurable effect over great distance. And just like a curveball you would aim to the left or right and have it curve back in.

2 out of 60 people found this comment helpful
I found this comment 
 
Page 1 of 3 123next ›last »
Flickr Block Header

Share your photos in the Pop Sci pool at www.flickr.com!
Current theme: Australia