Here's a US Perspective on the VR Headset War
Xavier Harding
at 11:30 AM Mar 4 2016
Here's a US Perspective on the VR Headset War
Oculus Rift hand controllers
Popular Science
Gadgets // 

Here in Australia, we're still reeling at the $1100+ price of both the Oculus Rift and the Vive. Yes, those are "first batch" units and you are paying for day-one access. Yes, VR will get cheaper in the years ahead. But still, come on! In the US however, the pricing is less blistering - not that our friends on the Popular Science Mothership in NY know how good they have it...

(Obviously all the prices in the following article are in US dollars.)

The Oculus Rift and the HTC Vive are on their way to market. After months of rumors and hype, you can now finally buy pre-order both virtual reality headsets online: the Oculus Rift went on sale first in January for $599 and is expected to ship in March, whereas the HTC Vive went on sale in late February for $799 and is expected to begin going out to buyers in April.

The Facebook-owned Oculus kicked off what we know to be the modern virtual reality wave, and many companies iterated on the company's ideas. Among them, but certainly not the only one, was Taiwanese electronics giant HTC. In a partnership with Valve, the folks behind PC service Steam (and game we've all spent too much time playing, Portal), HTC has devised its own VR helmet. And both are awesome.

With both virtual reality devices coming in 2016 and opening their doors for preorder, it can be tough to choose which one you'll get. But with price tags reaching the stratosphere, you'll want to make the right choice on your coolest PC accessory yet. Console-focused gamers, your VR priorities lie elsewhere. Those faint of wallet turn around now.

HTC Vive Pre
Xavier Harding/Popular Science
The newest HTC Vive cleverly puts a camera on the front of the device.

The best things in life are too expensive

Preordering the Oculus Rift will cost you $599. Putting money down for the HTC Vive will run you $799. HTC Vive hopefuls can look forward to their device arriving around May 2016 while Rift buyers can expect their VR helmets to start shipping in late March if you were quick to buy, or July 2016 if you buy yours right now.

And that's without considering the PC you'll either need to have already or purchase alongside your new headset...

For the HTC Vive, the PC required needs to have an Nvidia GeForce GTX 970, AMD Radeon R9 290 or better for GPU, Intel i5-4590, AMD FX 8350 or better for CPU, 4GB of RAM, an HDMI 1.4 port, DisplayPort 1.2 or later and a USB port of the 2.0 variety or higher.

The Oculus Rift minimum PC requirements are largely the same. GPU needs to be an Nvidia GTX 970, AMD R9 290 or something higher, CPU an Intel i5-4590 or higher, and HDMI 1.3 instead of 1.4. As for USB ports, the Rift requires three USB 3.0 ports and one USB 2.0 ports. And Oculus requires more RAM, at 8GB.

For either headset you buy, PCs of this caliber run at around $1,000. And that's a separate cost from the pricey VR headset.

The Oculus Rift, however, may bring a better pre-order bundle, if only for one title: EVE: Valkyrie. We played the space shooter back at Playstation Experience in December and a code for the game will come with  Oculus Rift units that are purchased right now.

In addition to EVE, Rift buyers will get Lucky's Tale. The game follows a tiny fox that looks a little like Tails from the Sonic the Hedgehog games of old. The platformer offers a very kid-friendly look and will likely serve as a good time-waster. Named after Oculus's founder Palmer Luckey? We'll never know.

Xbox One Controller
Microsoft
Xbox One Controller, ships with every Oculus preorder

What else you're getting for that price

The Oculus Rift comes with an Xbox One controller. Not quite one of Microsoft's Pro controllers, but a quality button-box nonetheless. If you own an Xbox One, the purchase of an Oculus Rift is even more beneficial for you. The Rift will also ship with an Oculus Remote, presumably for use with watching video in VR.

The HTC Vive on the other hand will ship with an HTC custom controller for each hand. While not an Xbox controller, they will be made for a VR experience and will allow for motion control out of the box. Oculus Rift's motion control-supporting controllers will arrive later this year.

Futureproofing & other considerations

Back at MWC 2016, we dubbed the HTC Vive the most futuristic VR headset around, still. The ability to walk around in virtual reality is something the Oculus supports, but HTC embraces. And features like the ability to connect your phone and see text and phone call notifications from within fire are a nice touch. Considering HTC has teamed up with Valve, we can expect that Steam will have greatest compatibility with the Vive and any games like Left 4 Dead, Portal or Half-Life 3 (confirmed) will hit Vive first. And the Vive has a camera on the front that lets you peak into the real world without removing the headset.

Oculus may not have a game delivery service on the level of Steam, but they do have the power of Facebook behind them. Oculus was acquired by the social network in 2014 for $2 billion. And Zuckerberg isn't looking to let that go to waste.

But it isn't just social apps, Oculus also has 100 games coming to the Rift this year, including Rock Band and Minecraft. And with the Samsung Gear VR, there's the possibility of apps that require less horsepower coming to Oculus's more high-end headset. We could even see a future where those really wanting to lighten their pockets would spend the extra $200 that the Vive demands on a Gear VR for the road. Perhaps one day this will be viable.

Oculus Rift hand controllers
Oculus
Oculus Rift controllers, coming after launch

And The Winner Is...

While both headsets are great, for now we'd have to recommend your pre-order go to the Oculus Rift. Provided you already have a PC, the Rift is $200 cheaper and comes with EVE: Valkyrie. And Xbone owners can look forward to the extra controller that comes with the VR headset.

The HTC Vive offers more advanced technology (the existence of a camera on the exterior cannot be understated). But until the software library offers a killer app that makes the device a must buy, Oculus's Rift is smarter pre-order.

comments powered by Disqus
Sign up for the Pop Sci newsletter
Australian Popular Science
ON SALE 01 FEBRUARY
PopSci Live